Trying to Convince an Aaron Judge Skeptic

Unless a meteor lands in the Bronx and halts baseball there for a month, the New York Yankees are heading back to the postseason. They have played good ball in September with a 12-7 record, and having won five of their last six contests. But it’s not September that is the critical month around here. It is October, and if the Yanks fail to win the World Series it will be looked at as a 16th consecutive failed season. No one knows that better than Aaron Judge, the best player in the game but owner of playoff statistics that are decidedly below average for a player of his stature. No one fails to remind me of this more often than my own flesh and blood.

Whenever the subject comes up about Judge, Ryan is always quick to point out his playoff failures. It could be a meme about his dropped flyball in Game 5 of last year’s World Series or a prediction about Judge striking out five times in two games in this year’s Wild Card round (if that is where they end up). No matter how great the regular season numbers end up, there will always be a, “yeah but” attached to his name. Judge will never be considered a true great Yankee unless he wins a title. The truth is, he is not alone in his thinking. I’ll bet there are thousands of Yankee fans, like Ryan, who see Judge as doomed to repeat underachieving postseasons. Someone between the ages of 7 and 17 will still believe that this time will be different. Or, it could be someone as old as say, me, knowing that eventually, greatness does shine through. Once upon a time, Alex Rodriguez was vilified for his playoff failures. Then, for one magical October in 2009, it all clicked for him as he was great from the Divisional round all the way to New York’s Game 6 World Series clincher. The same can happen to Aaron Judge in 2025. If he has a similar playoff run to that of Rodriguez in 2009, you can bet the Yankees will be raising their 28th championship banner.

After reading this, I doubt Ryan will change his mind. He will need to see proof before committing to saying, “Aaron Judge is great when it counts”. I don’t even think four home runs in round one will change his mind. No, for Ryan and all of the like-minded Yankee fans out there, greatness will only be considered when Judge gets a ring.

Author: Tom Lynch

Family is everything to me. Baseball is a close second. What better way to combine my two favorite passions than to write about them! My three children each have a different baseball team, hence the title, "Three Unassisted". I write about not only my thoughts but also the musings of Ryan (Yankees), Caitlyn (Phillies) and Matthew (Mets). I may have grown up a Yankees fan but since family is greater than ball, I also root for the Phillies and Mets. I love talking about my kids. I love talking about baseball. That lethal combination will keep you coming back for more. Happy reading! View all posts by Tom Lynch