Meet the New Yankees, Same as the Old Yankees?

I have been a skeptic that we were going to have a flurry of moves prior to the December 1 lockout date. Recent events, such as today’s big trade between the Seattle Mariners and Kansas City Royals, the return of Sonny Gray to the Minnesota Twins, and Jake Bauers joining the Boston Red Sox have slightly altered my thinking. I suppose with Tarik Skubal ‘s market narrowing to the New York Mets and Toronto Blue Jays, we have almost entered the free agent frenzy zone. Not to be outdone, the New York Yankees have re-upped with two of their own guys in relievers Tim Hill and David Bednar. They are also considering re-signing a third reliever, Paul Blackburn. In looking at the Yanks’ roster and knowing what they have done so far, the question needs to be asked.

Tweak the philosophy, Mr. Cashman. Credit: NY Post

Are the New York Yankees running it back….again?

When it comes to the everyday lineup and their positions, the only theorical open spot is at second base. However, with Anthony Volpe receiving time at the position toward the end of 2026, it is conceivable he is the front runner to claim the spot. Sure, there is talk about upgrading catcher and third base. I don’t believe the Yanks will shell out what it would take to grab Alec Bohm. A more realistic target could be Bohm’s former teammate Edmundo Sosa. They are more likely to run a platoon of Ryan McMahon and whomever they sign to solidify the hot corner. For catcher, Austin Wells‘s final two months will convince management to fortify, rather than upgrade behind the plate. Ryan Jeffers accepting the Qualifying Offer from the Twins took the only potential big Yankee target off the board.

Now, look at the rest of the team. Ben Rice and Luis Garcia Jr. will rotate at first base and designated hitter. General manager Brian Cashman has stated Giancarlo Stanton will be back and be an “impact bat”. He will get DH appearances as well. Volpe, barring something unforeseen, is at second, George Lombard Jr. mans shortstop while McMahon plus player X will be at third. The outfield is more set. From left to right, it will be Cody Bellinger, Spencer Jones and Aaron Judge starting with Heliot Ramos as the primary backup. Four out of five rotation spots are locked with Cam Schlittler, Gerrit Cole, Max Fried and Carlos Rodon. Rounding out are Ryan Weathers, Will Warren and Luis Gil all figuring to fight for number five. The bullpen figures to have one or two new faces but again, it won’t be anyone that represents a significant upgrade from last season.

What does it mean?

For starters, we will get another 90 wins. With Judge gone for half the year, the Yankees won 93 games, good for second place in the American League East. But does it represent an improvement? In a word, no. Running it back with the same group and expecting a deeper playoff push isn’t happening. This is an excellent regular season team who has not and will not address the number one flaw holding them back: the lack of tough at bats in the playoffs. Where is their David Hamilton? He’s the Milwaukee Brewers’ third baseman who is merely average in the regular season but put together one great plate appearance after another during Milwaukee’s championship run. Where is their Jackson Chourio, the star who gets the bat on the ball to advance runners so his teammates will drive them in? Find those players. When they do, then maybe we can talk World Series. Until then, enjoy the division round exits.

The Yankees need a slight philosophical change. Nothing too drastic. They are a perennial playoff contender. But in order to take the next step back to the World Series, they need their own version of Hamilton and Chourio. Unfortunately, the early returns are not so promising.


Discover more from Threeunassisted

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Unknown's avatar

Author: Tom Lynch

Family is everything to me. Baseball is a close second. What better way to combine my two favorite passions than to write about them! My three children each have a different baseball team, hence the title, "Three Unassisted". I write about not only my thoughts but also the musings of Ryan (Yankees), Caitlyn (Phillies) and Matthew (Mets). I may have grown up a Yankees fan but since family is greater than ball, I also root for the Phillies and Mets. I love talking about my kids. I love talking about baseball. That lethal combination will keep you coming back for more. Happy reading!

Leave a Reply